Two weeks ago, the conservative movement in the U.S. suffered a devastating defeat. Not only did Democrats win back control of Congress, but the party flipped more than 400 districts that Donald Trump won in 2024, and 94 percent of counties shifted an average of 13 points to the left. The supposed popular mandate that welcomed Trump back into office now appears more like an embarrassing lapse of judgment that the country is experiencing collective hangxiety over.
On the surface, right-wingers are in retreat. MAGA influencers are hanging up their red hats and declaring themselves bamboozled (yeah, right). Podcasters who endorsed Trump are backtracking. Elon Musk’s cybertrucks are being discontinued. But brewing just below that feigned ignorance over how bad Trump 2.0 was going to be, I can see the outline of a conservative cultural pushback starting to form.
It’s eerily reminiscent of where the Republican base was back in 2018 and 2020, after the first Trump-inspired blue wave and when he lost his initial re-election bid to Joe Biden. It seemed like Democrats had recaptured mainstream sentiment, chasing the winds of progressive social movements like #MeToo and Black Lives Matter. And yet, conservatives spent the next four years fomenting enough backlash and revisionist history around these pivotal periods that their culture warmongering carried them back into the White House.
I don’t want to see that happen again, to say the least. And it doesn’t have to. We can be more cognizant, discerning, and vocal about the ways conservatives are warping cultural advances into reactionary pipelines and playbooks.
This is a great time to start, because they’re caught in a particularly weak moment. The usual tactics aren’t working. I want to zoom in on two cases where they’re trying (and failing) to use anti-#MeToo sentiment to their advantage: the conviction of British comedian Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault, and Paramount’s cinematic comeback of Johnny Depp where he uttered the line “Grant me the grace to prove that I am no longer the man that I once was.” No thank you!

Johnny Depp as Scrooge in Paramount’s Ebenezer and Russell Brand arriving at Southwark Crown Court in London, United Kingdom on November 4, 2026. (Photo by Zeynep Demir/Anadolu via Getty Images)
The Rebranding of Russell Brand Isn’t Working
Two days after polls closed in the US, a jury across the ocean in London unanimously convicted Brand of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault involving four women between 2004 and 2009. He was soon sentenced to ten years behind bars. And simultaneously, prominent American conservatives began declaring this all quite unfair.
Trump’s son Don Jr. took to the alt-right livestreaming platform Rumble to suggest Brand’s conviction was motivated by his embrace of Christianity. Former Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly engaged in the kind of grotesque victim-blaming and rape denial she has become known for. The Make America Healthy Again movement’s official Substack declared the evidence against Brand was too weak. Jeffrey Epstein skeptic Michael Tracey threatened to publish the name of one of Brand’s anonymous victims, a retaliatory tactic he and Kelly previously teamed up for in their attacks on the Cornell University gang rape victim.
A slew of other pro-Trump pundits across social media performed the same song and dance about Brand’s disproven innocence and pushed outlandish conspiracies that the British legal system was targeting religious conservatives with this case. It’s ridiculous on its face, and it also racked up headlines and engagement.
One reason why they’re doing this is obvious: after a bombshell 2023 investigation surfaced rape and abuse allegations against Brand, he made a sudden pivot to Christianity, got baptized, and embarked on the same podcast circuit featuring a number of his now-staunch defenders. Just look at how much Kelly changed her tune from 2023 to 2026, once Brand appeared on her show. This is a mutually beneficial content ecosystem for its participants.
But beyond the simple economics, the propaganda that conservative rapists are being targeted for their political beliefs is a compelling excuse for voting for them anyways. It’s how Trump stayed afloat despite his close Epstein association, his loss to E Jean Carroll, and dozens of other accusations. Rape culture is foundational to both patriarchy and conservatism, directly benefits Republican leadership, and attracts adherents from across the political spectrum into voting red.
On the bright side, the UK justice system seems to care a little more about the sanctity of Brand’s conviction than the US Supreme Court cares about letting felonious presidents commit crimes in office. After Brand’s wife shared a message from him on YouTube this weekend where he claimed he was “not guilty,” he faces disciplinary action for violating prison rules. Unlike other men who defended themselves in the wake of #MeToo allegations, he’s going to be on a tight leash for the next decade.
But popular opinion on Brand’s case outside those walls is more malleable. Just like we saw with Depp in 2022, a dedicated contingent of supporters can morph into a politically resonant faction of its own if there’s enough fuel added to the fire.
Depp’s Redemption Film Flopped

Johnny Depp dressed as Ebenezer Scrooge at "Collider's Directors on Directing" panel at the 2026 Comic-Con International: San Diego held at the San Diego Convention Center on July 23, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Michael Buckner/Variety via Getty Images) The addition of the tomato emoji was mine.
I’ve already written about how Paramount’s Ebenezer film, a nonsensical “prequel” to A Christmas Carol starring Depp as Scrooge, is a vehicle to sell his supposed redemption arc and combat the cultural gains of the #MeToo movement. I based my analysis off the trailer and the studio head David Ellison’s political affiliations, which meant it was more of an educated guess. But now that the movie is in theaters, I can confirm I was right.
Of course, I didn’t actually pay to see it. But professional film critics did, and the savvier ones decoded how Ebenezer was an obvious play on Depp’s real-life attempts to undermine his ex-wife Amber Heard’s abuse allegations. “As he rehashes the eccentric tics that have defined his performances across his career, he’s banking on audiences forgetting the public turmoil that’s consumed his life over the past several years and remembering only the Jack Sparrows and Willy Wonka,” wrote Taylor Williams for Slant Magazine.
It can’t be overstated just how much Depp’s 2022 defamation trial against Heard in Virginia contributed to the reactionary backlash against #MeToo and the undergirding of the #MenToo movement. While previous attempts to smear survivors like Christine Blasey Ford were more popular among conservatives, the “Justice for Johnny Depp” campaign attracted people on all sides of the aisle and established a viral pipeline into the waiting arms of conservative media.
Depp was already falling out of favor with Hollywood before Depp v. Heard, thanks in part to his unprofessional behavior on-set and inability to memorize his lines, but under Ellison’s direction, Paramount is hiring back several men accused at the height of #MeToo. It’s part of a broader conservative media takeover, calcified further today with the announcement that Elon Musk has invested in Skydance.
But again, there’s a silver lining: the Ebenezer box office opening weekend was a tepid $19 million in the US, coming in under projections of up to $25 million. And on Rotten Tomatoes, critics have given it a paltry 54% rotten rating. Given that Depp superfans would have likely secured tickets early and the theater lineup is about to be packed with a Hunger Games installment, a Meet the Parents sequel with Ariana Grande, and other Thanksgiving entries, I don’t think Ebenezer will be the runaway blockbuster that his defenders dreamed about. It looks more on par with the previous run of theatrical disappointments that Depp was already known for before Heard even filed for divorce.
I was holding my breath for this one, because I was a little afraid that Depp and Paramount were going to rekindle the excitement of the 2010s that Depp’s character acting used to conjure up. One reason I suspected they might succeed is because the industry trade publications like Variety, the Hollywood Reporter, and Deadline have been promoting Ebenezer like they’re on the payroll. And given their access journalism model, they kind of are.
Eagle-eyed commentators have found it a bit strange that these publications are so willing to go to bat for Depp when they’ve previously undersold the success of movies like Sinners. I think part of it is that these Hollywood institutions aren’t nearly as liberal as Republicans would have you believe. They’re instrumental in rehabilitating and whitewashing the careers of abusive men while propping up the status quo that leaves more diverse creatives in the margins.
This is why I don’t turn toward establishment media of any kind to quell conservative campaigns or stop them from recapturing the mainstream. They have always been fickle and ineffective at holding Trump and conservatives accountable and working toward a better world. Independent media has actually driven progressive change, rewritten tired narratives, and skewered Republican lies. We’ll continue to hold the line well after the high of winning the midterms balances out.

